Reality of NRC and NPR | Explained by Dhruv Rathee


Hello friends Think about it : you voted for the politicians during the time of elections They formed the government After voting and the forming of the government , they come to you And tell you that you have to prove that you are the citizen of this country You prove that you are the citizen of this country You’d question what logic this is: you weren’t asked anything before casting the votes Then they had to secure votes They’re asking for votes after casting of votes Here, take this voter ID card as proof No. Voter ID card is not proof that you are the citizen of this country Then you’d say ; Here, take my Aadhaar Card. I had given my finger prints for Aadhaar card No. Aadhaar card is also not a proof that you are a citizen of this country PAN Card is also not a proof that you are a citizen of this country Passport is also not a proof that you are a citizen of this country This is their new nationwide NRC logic I’m not saying this. This has been said by our country’s Home minister, Amit Shah himself in his latest Times Now interview Here, listen to it So this Aadhaar, this voter card and all the other types of documents Are they not proof of citizenship? No. They are not They do not determine citizenship. And especially not by Aadhaar Voter ID card, Aadhaar card, passport- none of these are proof of citizenship This has been said by a report by the New Indian Express which has been sourced by government officials In the last video, I had explained about the Assam NRC, but Home Minister Amit Shah, in his latest interview, has said that the nationwide NRC would be different from the one in Assam That procedure would not be carried out So , on the basis of his interview and on the basis of the speeches of our Prime Minister and on the basis of the official statements issued on behalf of the government Come, let us see what this nationwide NRC could be and how it could appear And what is this NPR? and how would it work? Now you could probably ask here that why am I even talking about a nationwide NRC? Because our Prime Minister, in his latest speech, has said that there are no plans for NRC Ever since his government was formed, they have never mentioned NRC No detention centres have been built in our country One thing I’d like to say is that I have never seen a bigger liar than our Prime Minister in my entire life He openly lies in loud voices Here, take a look After the formation of my government, right from 2014 until today, I’d like to tell the 130 crore citizens of the country nowhere have we talked anything about the word NRC There have been no talks Maybe he feels like if he says it while bobbing up and down and screaming, then people will believe his lie to be the truth Actually, you know what, this is a propaganda technique, a logical fallacy which is called große Lüge in German- a big lie This was mentioned or the first time by the famous dictator of Germany, the name of whom you might know The meaning of it is to utter such a humongous lie that the listener feels that such a huge lie is being uttered by such a great person with such great confidence, then this thing can not be a lie. It must be the truth And this is how people are be-fooled and misled The truth is that Amit Shah, in not one, not two, but in 7-8 speeches, over the past 5 years, has talked about nationwide NRC time and again Repeatedly, he has said that nationwide NRC would be brought in We are clear on this: there will be an NRC in this country The process of NRC will happen countrywide We will bring in the National Register of Citizens throughout the country Understand the chronology: First, the CAB will come After the coming of CAB, the NRC will be brought in And the NRC will not be brought in only for Bengal It will brought in for the entire country No, it should be enforced throughout the country Its name is itself is National Register of Citizens There has been no discussion on the word NRC There have been no talks Then Modiji said in his speech that there are no detention centres in the country Another great example of this propaganda technique Neither (are they ) being sent to detention centres nor are there any detention centres in India Brothers and sisters This is a white lie This is a game of foul intentions It is a nefarious sport If detention centre is a rumor, then what is this in Assam? Have 40 crore rupees been spent to construct a shopping mall in Assam? And is a children’s playground going to be constructed in Karnataka? Hmm? It is 120 kilometers away from Guwhati and the construction that you can see here It is an exclusive detention centre to house the declared foreigners in Assam Prior to this, the foreigners were kept in jails So you are saying that this detention camp that is being constructed is a part of this process? No, the government prepares in advance.. the legal process is still ongoing To tell you another interesting fact, the people in these detention camps are both Hindus and Muslims There are a lot of people crying to prove citizenship Look at this video of these people in these detention camps that was shot by BBC They took a housewife like me and threw me in jail My legs are swollen due to sleeping in the jails In one room, there are 50-55 people We have to sleep in front of the bathrooms What sin did I commit that I was thrown in jail for three months at this age? If I have to go the jail again, I’ll go , but I will prove that I am Indian The people being interviewed were Hindu By the way, I should tell you that if you have this misconception that this will affect the Muslims more and if you’re Hindu, you’d be safe Earlier, I used to feel the same Hearing the old speeches of Amit Shah, I used to feel that this would have a bigger effect on Muslims But after listening to his latest interview it seems that The NRC will affect all- irrespective of whether you are a Hindu or a Christian First, let me make it clear: there will be no proceedings in NRC on the basis of any religion Whosoever will be found to not being a citizen of India under NRC- all will be weeded out This is one thing So it would be wrong, according to me, to say that NRC is solely for the Muslims And do you know what the reality is? The reality is that whenever such a scheme is implemented in our country, The biggest harm will be inflicted upon the common man and poor people Consider it: how any people have their birth certificates? Leave aside the(birth certificates) of the parents and the grand parents How many poor people would possess their own birth certificates? There would be so many people whose houses would have been swept away in floods Where would they procure any documents from? Now the thing is that the people who have money, they’d get their setting done. They would get counterfeit birth certificates made- or something like that But the poor people would face the most trouble If you can recall, something similar had happened during the time of demonetization They had said that due to demonetization, the people with black money would face a lot of problems But what happened in reality? The people who had money gave commissions to get their black money converted into white money A new business had flourished Come, give your black money here. We’d deduct a percentage of it and then get your black money converted into white money And this is what happened. Hence, in reality, you would have noticed all the money finally returned to banks after demonetization So who bore the loss? The biggest loss was borne by the common man and the poor people who had to stand in queues for weeks There were job losses and they lost their businesses The businesses that were actually thriving got shut down The GDP fell and the economy faced a loss of lakhs and crores of Rupees Just like in demonetization, there is Zero planning on the part of the government in NRC too Why am I saying this? Because, you yourself think about it : A scheme in which our Prime Minister says one thing The Home Minister says the opposite, another minister says something else which disagrees with both So the government itself is not clear about what it wants I’d still maintain that in my opinion, the real reason why the government is doing this is because this NRC, CAA, They want to distract the people They want to distract people from the fact that economic slowdown has increased The GDP is plummeting, there are so many job losses taking place, the businesses are declining. In fact, in a latest report the OECD, has revealed that due to economic slowdown, our country has faced a loss of 2.8 lakh crore rupees Think about how big of a figure this is 2.8 lakh crore But what does our government say? No, we will spend crores of rupees to construct detention centres We will spend crores of rupees to conduct the NRC I’d said that in the NRC of Assam, there was a scam of more than 1,600 crore rupees We’d spend money to conduct the NRC despite that Now they have come up with a new thing: they say, they will conduct an NPR NPR means National Population Registers The government has just sanctioned almost 4,000 crore rupees to get this conducted Basically, this is an exercise in which government officials would go to all the people living in the country And collect their data Now the government says that this is being done for the census 2021 And by the way, NPR is not a new thing NPR was also conducted in 2010 but there are a few main differences Now, the NPR that is being conducted now and the 2010 NPR According to reports, this time in NPR, there is a section in which they ask you about the place of birth of your parents and about their date of birth So this is one thing that links the NPR with the NRC Because we’d seen in the case of Assam that things like parents’ and grandparents’ birth certificate were required in order to prove the citizenship of people So the people who’d come out as doubtful in the NPR, NRC would be applied upon them There is one thing I’d like to say here Amit Shah had said in his interview on 24 December, 2019 that NPR and NRC have no relations. There are no links of any kind between them There is no relation between these two processes Neither can these two processes be used to conduct each other The process that will be commenced for NPR can never ever be used for NRC There are two separate laws for this But this was a lie The reality is that on 26th November, 2014, the government’s own people had said in the Rajya Sabha that NPR is the first step to NRC and I have provided the link of this proof in the description if you do not believe me You can check for yourself It is on the government’s own website Not just this, The Home ministry’s own annual report of 2018-19 states that that NPR is the first step to NRC And this has been mentioned by the government not once, twice but in total 9 different times that there is a link between the NRC and the NPR NPR is the first step to NRC What I don’t understand is why the people in the government lie so much to the people What do they have to lose if they say it clearly? Then I think about it and realise that they lie because There can be only one reason Distract the people. Confuse the people Distract the attention of the people from the real issues I see no other reason What do you think? You can write down in the comments below Due to a strong link between the NPR and the NRC The chief ministers of West Bengal and Kerala have said that in their states the NPR exercise will not take place and it has been stopped I hope you would have liked this video. Share it If you like my work and if you want to see such informative, knowledgeable videos in the future then you can support me on Patreon.com/DhruvRathee Because it is because of the funding by people like you that I am able to make such videos I have no big political sponsors like the mainstream media there are no huge political sponsors This channel runs only because of crowdfunding due to which you are able to see videos like this So, we will meet in the next video Thank you

100 thoughts on “Reality of NRC and NPR | Explained by Dhruv Rathee

  1. 1:52 Truth vs Lies of NRC
    3:57 Reality of Detention Centres 
    6:36 Who will be impacted by NRC? (Opinion)
    9:06 What is NPR?
    10:01 Relation of NPR with NRC

  2. So dhruv rathee kindly make a video on the death of 91 childrens in rajasthan i know u do not have guts to do this but don't worry chamchas will continue to call u liberal

  3. Please make a video on our original citizenship act and it's amendments…..I gave it a reading…. though many terms were too legally technical for me….but as I understood it ….it is already necessary to have an Indian parent to be a Indian citizen after the 1987 amendment…..of course there other ways to become an Indian citizen too….it will be really helpful if you sir can make a video as in what are the rules that were already present before this Citizenship Amendment Act of 2019

  4. तेरे को समर्थन करने वाले ईस देश मे आग लगा रहे है और तू यही चाहता है, कुल मिला कर तू एक वेल पैकेज में एंटीनेशनल मूवमेंट्स के लिए काम कर रहा है, तेरी लॉजिकल बात करने की अदा हो सकता है तुझे पसंद करने वालो को टेक्निकली सही लगे लेकिन तू अपना एक एजेंडा चला रहा है, हो सकता है इकोनॉमी और देश के कई आंतरिक मुद्दे पर तेरा एनालिसिस सही हो लेकिन राष्ट्रीय मुद्दे जो इतने सालो से सिर्फ इस वजह से हल ना हो सके क्योंकि एक मजहब विशेष के सेंटीमेन्ट हर्ट न हो जाये, और इनके सेंटीमेंट हर्ट न होने के चक्कर मे भारत मे सेक्युलिरिजम की आज में ये चारो तरफ खुरापात कर रहे है , इस देश की सांस्कृतिक विरासत ध्वस्त हो रही है ये देश अपने हजारों सालों की पहचान और अस्तित्व खो रहा है, बाजार लगा हुआ है देश विरोधी भीड़ का, एक बहुत बड़ा शातिर नेक्सस काम कर रहा है, ऐसा कैसे हो सकता है कि मोदी हमेशा हर चीज़ में गलत हो जैसा कि तू बताता है, मैं जानता हूं gst से आर्थिक तौर पर उथल पुथल मच गई, नोटबंदी उतनी सफल नही हुई जितना bjp ने ढिंढोरा पीटा, और बाकी कुछ और चीज़ों के लिए भी पीटती रहती है लेकिन मैं ये मानने को तैयार नही की 370 हटाना सही नही है, राम मंदिर से बड़ी इस देश की क्या पहचान हो सकती है, और तुम जैसे लोगो को ये भी नही पच रहा है, और जो देश की सुरक्षा के लिए खतरा बने हुए है जो इस देश के नागरिक है ही नही उन्हें इस देश मे रहने का हक़ क्यों, इनका जेहाद के नाम पर कत्ल करने वाली मानसकिता से देश वर्षो से यातनाये झेल रहा है इसीलिए राष्ट्रीय मुद्दे जो देश के लिए बेहद ज़रूरी है उन्हें अगर मोदी सरकार द्वारा पूरा किया जा रहा है तो हम सब उनके साथ है, तुम अपना प्रोपोगेंडा चलाओ कोई दिक्कत नही, मैने काफी पहले किसी और मुद्दे में तेरे वीडियो देखें थे मुझे लगा तू बेहद जोरदार और नॉलेज वाला बन्दा है लेकिन धीरे धीरे मझे समझ आ रहा है कि तू एक एजेंडे की तरह टेक्निकल लॉजिकल मिठा जहर फैला रहा है जो तेरे वीडियो देखेंने वालो को तार्किक रूप में सही लगता है, जो ज्यादा पढ़े लिखे नही है उनको तेरी आधी से ज्यादा बाते सर की ऊपर से जाएगी लेकिन जो एजुकेटेड है उनके दिमाग से खेलेगी, देश विरोधी तत्वों का बहुत बड़ा नेक्सस चल रहा है देश के अंदर के गद्दार और इनको समर्थन करने वाले नेता देश विरोधी राजनीतिक दल, पाकिस्तान, ब्रिटेन, इंडिरेक्टली अमेरिका, हमेशा भारत को अशांत और अस्थिर रखना चाहते है, और तू इन्ही लोगो मे से किसी एक का मोहरा है, जो अपना काम बड़ी ही चतुराई से कर रहा है।

  5. Kuch acha se vidieos banana Bhai kaikeliye modi ka piche lagga he tu de Bhai Mera pass bi acha khassa YouTube channels he Tera pholle khollu kya bol ,,,, Jane de modi ne Kya galti Kiya he ow battaa tu acha Kya Kya Kiya ow bol mat ok

  6. Ye baat sahi hai logo ka dhiyan main mudda se hata ke logo ko confuse kar rha hai
    Or ek baat Jahan tak mujhe samjh aa rha hai ki Kuch dino me ELECTION hone wala hai DELHI, CALCUTTA, BIHAR or UTTAR PRADESH ME usse bhi NRC ya CAA ka Link hai Vote Banking ke liye

  7. Bc peleh toh amit sah aur modi ko mago bc document .. Aur bhai jo koi sai bowll ra he na nrc aana chaye peleh dekh le document he tere pass laura bc

  8. You are right brother, same as demonization poor will die to prove himself is indian. Same one poor death to prove his 500 which he got yesterday after hard work is not black money.

    Andh bhakto samal jao warna dusro ko marte marte khud ludak jaoge

    Thanks dear to make this type of video.

  9. Waah video clips v NDTV ……Proof tum khud kr diye ……Sirf BJP ka expose krte ho aap…..Agr sach me democracy ka khyal hai toh ek video at least ek video bna do about against BJP party…

  10. I completely agree with you that they are trying to divert our attention from the economy as they have messed it up so bad that only miracles can put it back on track (Humans can't).

  11. Even if Indian Govt. is doing Good Work..

    You (Dhruv Rathi) are programmed to find flaws in it..

    I am a 1947 partition Punjabi migrant into india and I dont fear this NRC. Let it be done.

  12. Pese wala insaan kabhi desh chor kr nai aata……….
    …Jab tak ghotaala na ho.
    Aur gareeb insaan tab aata hai…….. Jab pese na ho. To kahin na kahin mai manta hu ki is cheez ka to koi end hi nai hai. Logo ko ese hi aane bhi nai de sakte aur na bhaga sakte.

  13. Samaj nhi aa raha tuj jese bewakuf k itne subscribers kese he tuje kisi bhi chiz k bare me kuch pata nhi h or aadhi adhuri bato me tu apna masala mix kar k logo ko bewakuf bana raha he
    Pahele tu hilna dulna bandh kar itne hath or ungliyo ko hila k Kyu. Bat karta. He ? Sale sabhi desh drohi yahi ka kha k desh k sath gaddari karte ho kuch to. Sharm karlo
    Mullo ki aaj China me kya halat he ye tum logo ko nhi dikhta kya vaha ki bat Kyu nhi karte kamino

  14. Heads off to your research and outcome.
    But brother i think we do have atleast an idea about how many indians are really migrants here (this is also safe for tracking terrorism activity) and then the process be done then poor ( which constitute half of the india) who are really the citizen but don't have proff. They all are gonna be huge huge number which is also a vote bank for BJP and they(bjp) can't afford so they will surely find a way to deal with it.

  15. Dhruv Bhai… Than how we can deal with NPR now…? What is your opinion about NPR, did we can give information about the NPR or not? As we know that its almost 2020 now NPR is going to be held this year… !!! Kindly suggest ASAP.

  16. Matlab pehle caa aayega jis ki wajah se Muslims ke sivay sabhi logo ko citizenships mil jayega . Baad me nrc ka fayda hi kya haiii

  17. मुसलमानों ने अपना अलग देश बांग्लादेश और पाकिस्तान ले लिया है, इसीलिए मुसलमानों का भारत में रहने का कोई हक नहीं है। मुसलमानों ने अखंड भारत का करीब 35% क्षेत्रफल ले लिया है। बांग्लादेश और पाकिस्तान दोनों का क्षेत्रफल मिलाकर विभाजन से पहले अखंड भारत का लगभग 35% होता है उसमें बांग्लादेश पाकिस्तान और पाकिस्तान के कब्जे वाले जम्मू कश्मीर का क्षेत्र शामिल है।

  18. Mr.Rathee you are a compulsive liar. Citizenship Certificate is needed. Do not call Respected Modiji a liar. Nobody trusts you. You will see Deshbhakt's Indians protesting against you in front of your home. This propaganda done by you against India. SHUTUP.

  19. “1947 Muslims who are opposing Pakistan will spend rest of their lives proving loyalty to India” Muhammad Ali Jinnah. He was right

  20. Guys calm down Dhrub is instigating common man when things start we all will see and experience nothing is going wrong with none.
    Jai Hind

  21. ध्रुव हम सब कितना भी वीडियो दिखा दें चाहें कितने भी सत्य दिखा दो , आरएसएस प्रचारित हिंदुत्व के दम पर चल रही यह राजनीती किसी भी तरह से हार नहीं सकती . हमको चाहिए की सबसे पहले आरएसएस प्रचारित हिंदुत्व को झूठ साबित किया जाये . मैं तुमको पूरी रिसर्च एक बाद बता रहा हूँ की इस हिंदुत्व को वेदों के आधार पर झूठ साबित किया जा सकता है . तुमको बहुत से लोग देखते हैं , तुम अगर एक वीडियो आरएसएस प्रचारित हिंदुत्व को वेदों के हिसाब से झूठ कह दो , तो इनका हिंदुत्व कमजोर होगा और भारत का भला होगा

  22. Thanks dhruarathi. For this information 🙏🙏🙏🙏👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯

  23. All fake news by this gentleman. It is very clear who sponsors him for spreading disharmony and falsified information about the government. Useless swine.

  24. We have been raised by manusmriti in India, somewhere strictly somewhere faintly. We all know what evil is going on in our country but how can't anyone connect the dots and understand that. It baffels me..!!🙄🙏🏿

  25. Now worst with these issues in front. BJP government now has invited Chinese company Huwei for 5g technology trials in india. For benifit of private companies the bjp government has risked the security of country

  26. तुम्हारी वीडियो में एक साल से देख रहा हूं. अभी २ दिन पहले सदगुरु जी ने एनआरसी पर वीडियो बनाई हे उसपे आपके क्या विचार है । कोन सही कोन गलत कुछ समझ नहीं आ रहा अब

  27. Whats wrong with NRC? Only banana republics won't have it. Dhruv, hating Modi is fine but opposing NRC is non sense.

  28. Hindustan Muslims satyaharichandras, then all three states have own NRC s to protect their counties. Why not India NRC
    Jai Hind

  29. VERY   TRUE   DHRUVA  RATHI  JI  :   ALL THE   PEOPLE  OF  OUR  WILL BE  EFFECTED ,  THESE  ARE  BAD  DAYS  OF  OUR  COUNTRY.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *